#24. What Condition is it in?

One of the most important considerations when buying vintage is the condition. Reputable dealers will readily disclose any flaws and many have devised a list of general categories the customer can refer to. On my site the categories are as follows.

Mint: Never used, no visible flaws.

Excellent : Barely used, no visible flaws

Very Good: Worn, but still in good shape. May have small flaws or
repairs, which are explained. The repairs are not noticeable.

Good: Worn but in good shape. Has small flaws or repairs which
are explained. On close inspection they are usually
noticeable but don't affect the appearance of the item when
worn.

Fair : These items have flaws or repairs which are noticeable and
are addressed. I avoid flawed merchandise as a rule, so most
of these pieces have redeeming qualities which I usually
explain or comment on

Most of our web merchandise is in the excellent category. It makes things simpler for all. In the shop I am SLIGHTLY less fussy because the customer is able to see first hand the vintage condition and determine if it is up to their standards. Still I am very particular. Most people who buy vintage understand that it has been around for sometime and will not appear like brand new off the rack merchandise. However they do expect a certain level of quality. When you buy your vintage from a good dealer you will be paying retail and can expect these pieces to be without significant flaws. We do the hunting, mending and often the cleaning so you don't have to. I'm proud to say our customers truly appreciate the consistently fine condition of our merchandise and consider the price well worth it. Still many of my customers occasionally like to hunt for vintage treasures at flea markets and charity shops. It's fun and there are great bargains to be found. I highly recommend this but there are some things to keep in mind about condition.

Fabric and leather are susceptible to the elements and even if a garment was never worn it could still have suffered damage. Most common are fading, mildew damage and moth damage. As well as perspiration stains, split seams, old attic smell, missing buttons, broken zippers and other types of stains. There are some things that can be restored. The big question being what problems are and are not possible to correct.


As a rule underarm stains on natural fibers are not removable. The salts and proteins in perspiration react with the dyes in the fabric and fade them permanently. Back when women threw nothing away they might save such a garment by cutting out the stained area and inserting gussets stolen from the hem or by using a piece of matching fabric. Many women sewed their own clothing and kept the left over scraps for future mending. Today few have the time or skill to do this and to pay a good dressmaker would be costly. So for all intents and purposes perspiration stains are a fatal flaw. Perspiration stains are not to be confused with deodorant stains. The white powdery residue from deodorant can sometimes be laundered out especially from nylon, acrylic and polyester. If the item is synthetic and washable chances are you will be able to launder out deodorant residue.

Mildew is also very problematic. It has a terrible odor and produces ugly stains. Mildew does not just sit on the surface of material. It is a microscopic plant (mold) that invades the fibers and actually eats cellulose (cotton, linen, ramie, rayon). Clothing that has been kept in a damp warm environment will inevitably grow mildew. All natural fibers are susceptible to mildew damage and even synthetics can suffer if mildew is left on for extended periods of time. The stains are very stubborn and can be permanent. If mildew is caught in time the garment might be saved with care. The smell can be removed with thorough cleaning and drying in the sun (no dryer). Stains can be faded with oxi-clean or bleach but this is only possible on fabrics that can handle these products. I generally pass on vintage with mildew problems. If an item is special enough for me to attempt a rescue and if I am successful I tell the customer I have restored the garment. There can be no trace odor, stains or weak fabric resulting. Mildew damage is serious and I suggest you pass.

Fading is another sad situation. It is not just sunlight that fades fabric. Fabrics can fade just from exposure to impurities in the air. This is referred to as "gas fading". The most common areas are the shoulders and hem. There are people who can restore color to older textiles but the cost is terrific. It can run into hundreds of dollars and is mostly only done on museum quality pieces. However if the fading is minimal you might be surprised how hard it is to detect when the item is worn. Fading usually looks worse on the hanger. I suggest you put it on look in the mirror to see if the fading is noticeable then ask someone else what they think. The fading can't be fixed but you might be able to live with it.

Stains are another issue. Some are removable others absolutely not. I am fairly good at recognizing a stain that can be removed but even with my knowledge and experience I get fooled. The older a stain is the harder it will be to remove. If a dress was put in the attic 30 years ago with a stain on it you can pretty much bet it is there to stay. You might be able to fade it down but chemical changes have occurred to the dye and the color will never be the same. The easiest garments to clean are the synthetics polyester, acrylic and nylon. White cottons and linens are also fairly easy to remove spots from and they respond well to Oxi-Clean. I have a good stain removal guide on the website at this link. Stain Removal

If you buy vintage earlier than the 1940s you may have run into a problem called shattering. The material appears to split for no reason.1920s beaded dresses are notorious for this problem. Nothing you can do will fix this. The fabric has deteriorated. If it is just under the arms and was caused by perspiration you may be able to add gussets after cutting out the compromised fabric. Some of these dresses are worth this effort. If the shattering is across the shoulders or anywhere else forget it. Old silks are the worst. The textile manufacturers weighted these fabrics with heavy metal salts which over the years has destroyed the fibers.

OK enough bad news. There are some problems easier to fix than you think. If you come across something with a broken zipper don't be too quick to dismiss it. Sometimes the zipper slide just goes off track. If there are no broken or warped teeth you can remove the metal bar at the end of the zipper with pliers and thread the slide back on. Make sure you put a good strong tack with thread at the base to of the zipper to prevent it from opening. Also zippers are not as expensive to replace as you think. If it is a couture dress it will cost more because of the hand finishing but on most dresses they can just be put in by machine. The range is anywhere from as low as $15 to $50. To save money ask your seamstress if you can remove the old zipper saving her time and you a few dollars. Some will say no because they worry you may cause damage but others are just as happy not to have to do this tedious chore.

Missing buttons are an easy fix. Just snip off the remaining buttons and replace all with a new set. It is nice to try to match the era but modern buttons in a matching color will work just fine. It is best to use modern buttons that are simple so the styles don't clash. Another wonderful little secret is to dye vintage white Mother of Pearl buttons with Rit dye. That way you can have vintage buttons in any color you like. It is easy to do on the stove top just like you are dying a small piece of fabric. Make sure you dye more than you need. One or two may have hairline cracks you do not see and will not make it through the process intact. Plus it is nice to have extras in case you loose one.

Moth holes are the bane of my existence. I try to love all of Gods creatures but moths and me, we are mortal enemies. I think the last straw was when I bought a gorgeous 1950s Christian Dior cocktail dress in tissue wool crepe. I had not looked close enough and when I got home one entire shoulder was riddled with small holes. I tried to repair this but the fabric was so fine and there were so many holes it was a lost cause. To have it professionally rewoven would have cost more than the value of the dress. ARRGH! That was a bad one but not all moth damage is hopeless. If you have tweeds or textured wool's it is not that hard to reweave a small section or two. In order to exactly match the wool I try to tease a couple strands out of the hem allowance. I use these to stitch back and forth from behind a few parallel rows until the hole is filled. Then I weave in and out in the other direction. Press and voila no more moth hole! This takes practice and is time consuming but very satisfying when you can save a lovely vintage wool jacket, coat or skirt. I have an entire article on my enemy the clothes moth if you would like to learn more. Here is the link Moths.

A lot of older garments have split seams. Knits and bias cut garments have a lot of stress on the seams and they tend to split open. This does not doom the piece at all. If the fabric is still strong then it is quick and easy to stitch the seam back up. Holes are another story. If they are tiny pin holes a couple little stitches with matching thread will do the trick or you might not even bother if they are not apparent. Larger holes are a problem. Years ago especially during the depression women would steal a bit of matching fabric from inside a pocket or from the hem and make a neat patch. If you are really good at it and the hole is not too big the patch will blend well. If a hole is too big or there is no matching fabric try a decorative solution. A pretty applique, bow or even a fancy button over the hole might work if the location is convenient. Frayed necklines and sleeve edges can be doctored with trims or braid. If you are good with a needle you can reinforce a frayed edge with embroidery floss and a small even blanket stitch. The effect is quite handsome and sturdy. Make sure you pre shrink embroidery floss before using so it does not cause puckering after the first washing.

Finally if garments are clean but have that old "winter in the attic smell" a good shake out and a day in the fresh air might be all you need.
Happy Happy vintage hunting!

Return to table of contents